Skip to content

Roof problems: replace or not

Signs you need a new roof in the Denver metro

A Denver-area roof is probably due for replacement when the damage is spread across several slopes rather than one spot: widespread granule loss, cracked, curled or brittle shingles, a soft deck, repeated leaks, or hail bruising on many shingles. City rules can also make the decision: Centennial requires a full reroof once repairs exceed 25% of the roof, Thornton requires every damaged slope to be replaced entirely once a permit is needed, and Denver allows only two layers. A written, slope-by-slope inspection is what settles it.

Hail counts are our own tally of NOAA storm-event records; city rules come from each city's own document, read 2026-10-20.

An independent publisher, not a roofing contractor. Facts last checked . How we source.

On this page
  1. The short list
  2. From the ground
  3. From the attic
  4. After hail
  5. When the city decides for you
  6. Age, warranty and the last storm
  7. Repair or replace: a decision table
  8. What to do next
  9. Common questions

The short list

SpreadDamage on several slopes, not one corner, points to replacement.
BrittleShingles that crack when lifted cannot be repaired cleanly.
Bare matGranules gone in patches or circles: worn out or hail-struck.
Soft deckA spongy feel or sagging line means water has reached the wood.
Two layersDenver allows two layers at most; a third means tear-off.
Repeat leaksThe same stain coming back after repairs.

From the ground

Do this with binoculars or a phone zoom on a bright day. Stay off the roof; a steep or icy slope is not a place for a homeowner, and walking on brittle shingles causes damage of its own.

  • Curling or cupping: shingle edges turning up or the middle sinking, typical of aged shingles on sunny south and west slopes.
  • Cracks and missing tabs across more than one slope.
  • Granules collecting in gutters and at downspout outlets in large amounts, or dark patches where the mat shows.
  • Sagging along the ridge or between rafters.
  • Flashing that is lifted, rusted or sealed with layers of caulk around chimneys and walls.
  • Dented metal: gutters, vents and window wraps, which shows hail of real size has hit the house.
  • Moss, debris or dark streaking that holds water against the shingles in shaded areas.

From the attic

The attic shows what the roof surface hides. Go up with a flashlight on a dry day and again after rain or snowmelt.

  • Daylight through the deck, other than at ridge vents.
  • Water stains, dark rings or rot on the underside of the sheathing, especially around chimneys, valleys and vents.
  • Damp or compressed insulation below a stain.
  • Frost on nail tips in winter, a sign of moist house air reaching a cold deck (see ice dams).
  • Spaced boards rather than panels on older homes, which may need an overlay at reroof.

Denver's 2025 Residential Code raised the ground snow load from 35 to 43 psf. That is a structural number, not a shingle one, but it is why the deck, its fastening and its drainage get checked on a tear-off.

Source: City and County of Denver, Community Planning and Development, "Snow Load Changes: 2025 DBC, 2024 IBC/IRC, ASCE 7-22".

After hail

Hail is the event most likely to end a Denver-area roof early, and it arrives unevenly. Across the seven metro counties, NOAA's storm-event files hold 869 hail reports for 2016–2025 on 143 separate hail days, 96% of them between May and August and 16.3% at 1.75 inches (golf-ball size) or larger.

Hail reports per year, seven Denver-metro counties, 2016–2025
Hail reports per year, seven Denver-metro counties, 2016–2025 2016: 75; 2017: 46; 2018: 124; 2019: 143; 2020: 20; 2021: 74; 2022: 15; 2023: 206; 2024: 111; 2025: 55 060110170220 2016 75 2017 46 2018 124 2019 143 2020 20 2021 74 2022 15 2023 206 2024 111 2025 55
Show the data as a table
YearReports
201675
201746
2018124
2019143
202020
202174
202215
2023206
2024111
202555

Source: NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information, Storm Events Database, details files d2006–d2025 (versions c20260323, c20260519, c20260625, c20260728, c20260819), counted 2026-10-20. Reports are point observations, not a measure of damage.

A busy year like 2023 does not mean every roof was hit, and a quiet year does not mean yours was spared. What matters is what fell on your street. UL 2218 rates impact resistance by dropping steel balls twice on the same spot: Class 1 is a 1.25-inch ball from 12 ft, Class 2 1.5 in from 15 ft, Class 3 1.75 in from 17 ft, Class 4 a 2-inch ball from 20 ft. To pass, the covering must not crack or split.

Hail damage on asphalt shingles shows as random bruises (soft spots where the mat is fractured), circular granule loss and cracks, spread across the slopes facing the storm. It often goes unnoticed until the shingles start losing granules months later. If a storm hit your area, the after-a-hail-storm checklist sets out the order of steps. The full year-by-year data is on the hail history page.

When the city decides for you

Sometimes the choice between repair and replacement is made by code, not by the roofer or the adjuster.

City rules that turn a repair into a larger job (read 2026-10-20)
CityRuleSource
CentennialRepairs over 25% of the roof area require a full tear-off and reroofCentennial reroof page
ThorntonOnce a permit is required, every slope with damaged shingles is replaced in its entiretyThornton Roofing Standards (9-12-25)
DenverTwo layers maximum; a third means tear-off to the deckDenver guideline, 2015 (verify)
LittletonPermit at 1 square or more in aggregate; up to 100 sq ft in any 365 days is a repairLittleton Policy 20-005

If a quote or an insurance scope proposes a partial repair that one of these rules would not allow, the scope needs to change before work starts. See roof permits by city.

Age, warranty and the last storm

Age alone is a weak signal; condition is a stronger one. Still, three dates are worth digging out before anyone inspects the roof:

  1. When the roof was installed. A closed permit on the city portal, a past invoice or the home inspection report from your purchase.
  2. Which product it is. The warranty paperwork or a leftover bundle wrapper, so the warranty terms can be read. See roofing warranties.
  3. When it was last hit. The date of the storm you suspect, which your insurer will ask for.

How your policy values the roof, at replacement cost or actual cash value, is set out on your declarations page. The Colorado Division of Insurance says wind and hail deductibles are often a percentage of coverage (1, 2 or 5 percent), so nothing is paid if the damage is below that amount; asks homeowners to request an itemized settlement and the exact policy language in any dispute; notes that supplements are possible and that public adjusters are licensed and optional; and suggests asking your insurer about discounts for hail-resistant roofs.

Source: Colorado Division of Insurance, consumer advisory: tips after hailstorms, read 2026-10-20.

Repair or replace: a decision table

What usually points each way
FindingPoints to repairPoints to replacement
ExtentOne area, one slopeSeveral slopes, or above a city threshold
Shingle conditionFlexible, granules intactBrittle, curling, bare patches
DeckDry and firmSoft, stained across bays
Leak historyOne leak with a clear causeRecurring leaks in different places
LayersOne layerTwo layers already (Denver limit)
HailDamage to vents or gutters onlyBruised or fractured shingles across slopes

What to do next

  1. DocumentDated photos from the ground and the attic.
  2. InspectA written, slope-by-slope report with photos. See roof inspections.
  3. Check coverageYour deductible and how the roof is valued, before filing.
  4. Compare quotesScopes that meet your city's rules, under a C.R.S. 6-22 contract.

The roof replacement guide covers the whole process, and the cost guide lists published Denver price ranges.

Common questions

How do I know if my roof needs replacing or just repair?

Repair fits isolated damage on a roof that is otherwise sound. Replacement is likely when damage is spread across several slopes, shingles are brittle or losing granules widely, the deck is soft, or a city rule forces it, such as Centennial's full-reroof rule for repairs over 25% of the roof or Thornton's whole-slope rule.

Can I tell if I have hail damage from the ground?

Sometimes. Dented gutters, downspouts, vents and window wraps are visible from the ground and show hail fell hard enough to dent metal. Bruised or fractured shingles usually need a close inspection by a professional on the roof.

Is granule loss a sign I need a new roof?

Some granules in gutters are normal on a new roof. Heavy, widespread loss that exposes the black mat, or granules gone in round spots after a storm, is a sign the shingles are wearing out or were hit by hail.

How often does the Denver area get hail?

Our count of NOAA storm-event records found 869 hail reports across the seven metro counties from 2016 to 2025, on 143 separate hail days, with 96% between May and August.

Does an old roof mean my insurer will not pay?

Not necessarily. Some policies pay the roof at actual cash value, which deducts depreciation, rather than replacement cost. Check your declarations page for how the roof is valued and ask your insurer in writing.

Get roofing quotes in the Denver metro

Free and no obligation. Tell us the job and ZIP; we check whether a partner roofer covers it before passing anything on.

Enter a Denver-metro ZIP (800–804). Outside that, we do not have a partner yet.
Please add your name.
A phone number is how the roofer reaches you.
Please add a working email.
Please add the street address for the job.
Get roofing quotes