Skip to content

Shingle comparison

Architectural vs 3-tab shingles for a Denver roof

Architectural shingles cost a little more than 3-tab in Denver, about $100–$150 a square in one company's published prices, and on a manufacturer's own spec sheets they come with far more wind warranty (130 mph against 60 mph), an impact rating, and a longer warranty term. Both can pass the same lab wind tests. In Thornton, a shingle off the city's list needs an 80 mph sustained or 90 mph gust wind warranty, which rules out a 60 mph 3-tab.

Specs from IKO's Dynasty and Marathon Plus AR product pages; prices from Gates Roofing (dated 2026-02-02); Thornton rule from its roofing standards (updated 12 September 2025). All read 2026-10-20.

An independent publisher, not a roofing contractor. Facts last checked . How we source.

On this page
  1. Spec sheets side by side
  2. Wind: the test vs the warranty
  3. Thornton's 80 mph rule
  4. Hail and impact
  5. Published Denver prices
  6. When 3-tab still makes sense
  7. Common questions

Spec sheets side by side

To compare like with like, we read one manufacturer's 3-tab and laminated shingle pages. Other brands differ in detail; the pattern is what matters.

IKO Marathon Plus AR (3-tab) vs IKO Dynasty (architectural), as listed
Spec3-tab: Marathon Plus ARArchitectural: Dynasty
ConstructionSingle layer with cut-out tabsTwo or more laminated layers (dimensional)
Exposure5 5/8 in5 7/8 in
Shingles per square6560
Coverage per bundle32.3 sq ft (21 shingles)33 1/3 sq ft (20 shingles)
Wind test classes listedASTM D3161 Class F, D7158 Class HASTM D3161 Class F, D7158 Class H
Limited wind warranty60 mph130 mph
Impact rating listedNone listedFM 4473 / UL 2218 Class 3
Fire ratingASTM E108/UL 790 Class AASTM E108/UL 790 Class A
Limited warranty term25 yearsLimited lifetime
Iron Clad (early-years) protection5 years15 years

Sources: IKO, Marathon Plus AR traditional 3-tab shingle specifications; IKO, Dynasty laminated (architectural) shingle specifications. Read 2026-10-20. Warranty terms are subject to the manufacturer's full limited warranty and installation requirements. Named as examples; we have not tested either product.

Note the coverage: about three bundles make a square for both, but the 3-tab uses more, smaller shingles. Waste and labor differ less than the price gap suggests; most of the difference is the product.

Wind: the lab test vs the warranty

Both example shingles list the same wind test classes, ASTM D3161 Class F and D7158 Class H. Two wind tests appear on shingle wrappers. ASTM D3161 (fan-induced) Class A, D and F correspond to 60, 90 and 110 mph. ASTM D7158 (uplift) Class D, G and H correspond to 90, 120 and 150 mph basic wind speed on the older ASCE 7-05 basis (about 115, 150 and 190 mph ultimate under ASCE 7-10).

Source: Professional Roofing (NRCA), wind resistance classifications for asphalt shingles, read 2026-10-20.

The warranty is where they part: 60 mph for the 3-tab and 130 mph for the architectural shingle. The test says how a new, properly sealed sample performed; the warranty says what the maker will stand behind on your roof. For a Front Range roof exposed to strong thunderstorm gusts, the warranty number is the one to put in the contract.

Wind numbers compared Bar comparison: 3-tab limited wind warranty 60 mph; Thornton minimum wind warranty for unlisted shingles 80 mph sustained; Denver 2015 guideline zones 90 to 110 mph; architectural limited wind warranty 130 mph. 3-tab wind warranty (Marathon)60 mphThornton minimum, unlisted shingle80 mphDenver 2015 zones (rating, not warranty)90–110 mphArchitectural wind warranty (Dynasty)130 mph
Different kinds of number: warranties (what the maker covers), Thornton's acceptance threshold, and Denver's 2015 required rating by location (90 mph at Federal Blvd to 110 mph at Kipling St; verify against the current code). Sources as cited on this page.

Thornton's 80 mph rule, and Denver's zones

Thornton's Building Inspection Division keeps a list of approved shingles by brand and product line. For anything else it says it "will consider any shingle that carries a national wind warranty for 80 mph sustained or 90 mph 3-second gust," with approval before the permit is issued. It also warns that "some manufacturers require that a warranty upgrade be purchased in order to be covered for the stated wind speed."

Source: City of Thornton Building Inspection Division, Roofing Standards (last update 9-12-25), read 2026-10-20.

Denver's 2015 Residential Roofing Guidelines take a different route: a required ASTM D7158 or D3161 rating by street centerline, from 90 mph at Federal Boulevard to 100 mph at Sheridan and 110 mph at Kipling. That guideline predates Denver's 2025 code, so ask the permit desk what applies now. Littleton's Policy 20-005, meanwhile, sets a six-nail minimum for every asphalt shingle, whatever its type.

Sources: City and County of Denver, Residential Roofing Guidelines (rev. 28 Aug 2015) (verify); City of Littleton, Policy #20-005, Roof Covering and Installation Requirements (5/14/2020, 3rd rev. 6/12/2023). Read 2026-10-20.

Hail and impact

In our example pair, the laminated shingle lists FM 4473 / UL 2218 Class 3 and the 3-tab lists no impact rating. UL 2218 rates impact resistance by dropping steel balls twice on the same spot: Class 1 is a 1.25-inch ball from 12 ft, Class 2 1.5 in from 15 ft, Class 3 1.75 in from 17 ft, Class 4 a 2-inch ball from 20 ft. To pass, the covering must not crack or split. Neither example is Class 4; impact-resistant lines are a third category, priced above standard architectural (see Class 4 shingles).

Source: GAF, Timberline AS II product page (UL 2218 test summary), read 2026-10-20.

Published Denver prices

Gates Roofing is the one Denver source we track that prints 3-tab and architectural separately.

Gates Roofing published installed price per square, Denver (2026)
Gates Roofing published installed price per square, Denver (2026) 3-tab: $350 to $450; Architectural: $450 to $600; Class 4 impact-resistant: $550 to $750 $0$200$410$610$810 3-tab $350–$450 Architectural $450–$600 Class 4 impact-resistant $550–$750
Show the data as a table
ShingleLowHigh
3-tab$350$450
Architectural$450$600
Class 4 impact-resistant$550$750

Source: Gates Roofing (Denver), dated 2026-02-02, read 2026-09-23. One contractor's published prices, not our quote.

On a 25-square roof, the published gap of $100–$150 a square comes to about $2,500–$3,750. The asphalt shingle cost page compares all four Denver sources.

When 3-tab still makes sense

  • A detached garage or shed where the city accepts the product and the roof will not be insured separately.
  • A matching repair on an existing 3-tab roof (if the product is still made), where a laminated patch would look out of place.
  • A short ownership horizon where the warranty difference does not matter to you.

Even then, check three things first: the city accepts the product (Thornton's list, Denver's wind rating), your insurer does not price the roof differently, and the contract names the exact shingle.

Common questions

What is the difference between architectural and 3-tab shingles?

A 3-tab shingle is one flat layer cut into three tabs; an architectural (laminated or dimensional) shingle bonds two or more layers for a thicker, textured look. On IKO's spec sheets the laminated Dynasty carries a 130 mph limited wind warranty, a UL 2218 Class 3 impact rating and a limited lifetime term, against 60 mph, no impact rating and 25 years for its Marathon Plus AR 3-tab.

Are 3-tab shingles allowed in Denver?

Denver's 2015 roofing guideline sets wind ratings by location (90 to 110 mph by street centerline) using ASTM D7158 or D3161 test classes, which many 3-tab products meet. In Thornton, shingles not on the city's approved list need a national wind warranty of 80 mph sustained or 90 mph gust, which a 60 mph warranty does not meet.

How much more do architectural shingles cost in Denver?

Gates Roofing publishes 3-tab at $350–$450 per square installed and architectural at $450–$600 (dated 2026-02-02). That is roughly $100–$150 more per square in one company's published prices, not a quote.

Do architectural shingles resist hail better?

Some are impact rated and many 3-tabs are not. IKO lists Class 3 for Dynasty and no impact rating for Marathon Plus AR. Neither is Class 4, the top UL 2218 class; Class 4 is a separate product line.

Get roofing quotes in the Denver metro

Free and no obligation. Tell us the job and ZIP; we check whether a partner roofer covers it before passing anything on.

Enter a Denver-metro ZIP (800–804). Outside that, we do not have a partner yet.
Please add your name.
A phone number is how the roofer reaches you.
Please add a working email.
Please add the street address for the job.
Get roofing quotes