On this page
Two warranties, two promisers
Most confusion about roofing warranties comes from treating them as one thing. They are two promises from two different companies, each covering a different failure.
| Question | Manufacturer warranty | Workmanship warranty |
|---|---|---|
| Who gives it | The company that made the shingles and accessories | The roofing contractor that installed them |
| What fails | A defect in the material | An installation error: nailing, flashing, ventilation, underlayment |
| Where the terms are | The maker's published warranty document for that product line | Whatever the roofer writes into your contract |
| Survives the roofer closing? | Yes; it is the maker's promise | Usually not |
| Covers hail? | Generally no; weather damage is an insurance matter | No |
Some manufacturers also sell "system" warranties that extend coverage when a certified installer uses the maker's full set of components. Those are still the manufacturer's promise, with its own conditions on who installed the roof and which parts were used. Ask which tier you are being sold and get the warranty's name on the contract.
What a manufacturer warranty covers
A shingle warranty is a promise about the product's material defects over a stated period, with conditions. When you read one, look for five things:
- The early-life window. Many warranties pay more generously in the first years, when a defect is most clearly the product's fault, then reduce coverage.
- What is paid. Material only, or material and labor, and whether tear-off and disposal are included.
- Wind coverage and its conditions. The wind speed the warranty covers, and what installation it requires to reach it.
- Transfer. Whether the warranty moves to the next owner of the house, and whether you must register the transfer.
- Registration. Whether the warranty must be registered after installation for the higher tier to apply.
Source: City of Thornton Building Inspection Division, Roofing Standards (last update 9-12-25), read 2026-10-20.
A worked example: one maker's published terms
To show what the five questions look like in practice, here is what one major shingle maker states for one widely sold product line. We use it because we could read it directly; it is not a ranking, and other makers' terms differ.
| Term | What the maker states | Question it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Early-life coverage | 10-year SureStart protection for early-life defects | How long the generous window lasts |
| Overall term | Lifetime limited transferable warranty | Whether it transfers; "limited" means read the definitions |
| Wind | 15-year 110 mph wind warranty; upgrade to 160 mph available, with CertainTeed starter and hip-and-ridge required | What installation the wind number depends on |
| Algae | 25-year StreakFighter algae-resistance warranty | Cosmetic coverage, separate from defects |
| Impact | UL 2218 Class 3 impact resistance | A test rating, not a hail warranty |
Source: CertainTeed, Landmark shingle product page (warranty and protection terms), read 2026-11-16. The binding terms are in the warranty document for the specific product line.
Compare those wind numbers with what Denver-area codes ask for. Two wind tests appear on shingle wrappers. ASTM D3161 (fan-induced) Class A, D and F correspond to 60, 90 and 110 mph. ASTM D7158 (uplift) Class D, G and H correspond to 90, 120 and 150 mph basic wind speed on the older ASCE 7-05 basis (about 115, 150 and 190 mph ultimate under ASCE 7-10). Denver's 2015 guideline set wind ratings by street centerline, from 90 mph at Federal Boulevard to 110 mph at Kipling Street; that guideline predates Denver's 2025 code, so confirm the current requirement with the city. On the west side of the metro, a warranty that only reaches its higher wind tier with specified accessories is a reason to make sure those accessories are on the quote.
Workmanship warranties
Most roof failures in the first years are installation problems: a missed flashing detail, nails placed high, a poorly sealed pipe boot, blocked intake vents. That is what a workmanship warranty is for, and it is entirely the roofer's document.
Nothing in Colorado's residential roofing law requires one. Before any roofing work begins, the roofer must give the owner a written contract signed by both parties, stating: the scope of work and materials; approximate dates; the approximate cost based on the damage known at signing; the roofer's physical address, email and phone; its surety and liability insurer, if any; its cancellation and deposit-refund policy, including full refund of a deposit if the owner rescinds within 72 hours of signing; the owner's rescission right under 6-22-104; and, when insurance pays, that the roofer cannot pay, waive or rebate the deductible. A warranty is not on that list, so the length, the scope and what happens if the roofer closes are whatever the roofer writes down.
Source: C.R.S. 6-22-103, Contracts for roofing services, read 2026-10-20.
Questions that separate a useful workmanship warranty from a slogan
- How many years, and does it cover leaks from flashing, penetrations and ventilation as well as shingles?
- Does it pay for interior damage caused by a covered leak, or only the roof repair?
- Does it transfer if I sell the house?
- What do I have to do to keep it valid (inspections, notice deadlines)?
- Is the company that signs my contract the company that gives the warranty, and is it licensed in my city?
The last question matters most after a hail season, when out-of-town crews work under local names. A warranty from an entity that is not on your city's license register, or that will not be in Colorado next year, is worth very little. The contractor checklist covers how to check.
Hail and warranties
In the Denver metro, the most common way a roof is destroyed is not a defect or a bad install; it is hail. The seven Denver-metro counties (Denver, Adams, Arapahoe, Jefferson, Douglas, Boulder and Broomfield) logged 869 hail events in the ten years 2016–2025, an average of 87 a year, with 16 percent of reports at 1.75 inches (golf ball) or larger. 96 percent of them fell between May and August. We counted them ourselves from the raw NOAA storm-event files rather than repeating a roofer's blog.
Hail damage is weather damage. It is the job of your homeowner's insurance, through the wind and hail coverage and deductible on your policy, not of the shingle warranty. An impact rating tells you how the shingle performed in a lab test; it does not obligate the manufacturer to replace it after a storm. UL 2218 rates impact resistance by dropping steel balls twice on the same spot: Class 1 is a 1.25-inch ball from 12 ft, Class 2 1.5 in from 15 ft, Class 3 1.75 in from 17 ft, Class 4 a 2-inch ball from 20 ft. To pass, the covering must not crack or split.
What voids a warranty
Exclusions are set by each warranty document, so read yours. These are the conditions that most often come up on Front Range roofs:
- Installation off-spec. Manufacturers tie coverage to their instructions. Thornton's photo inspections check the six-nail pattern and the shingle wrapper against the permit for exactly this reason.
- Mixed components. A higher wind tier or system warranty can depend on using the maker's starter and hip-and-ridge products, as CertainTeed's 160 mph Landmark upgrade does.
- Ventilation. Shingle instructions specify attic ventilation; an unvented or poorly vented deck runs hotter, and that can be grounds to deny a claim.
- Overlays and decks. Installing over an existing layer, or over spaced boards without an approved deck, can fall outside a warranty. Denver allows two layers at most; Littleton requires a panel overlay where board gaps exceed half an inch.
- Unregistered upgrades. If a warranty tier must be registered or purchased, skipping that step leaves you on the base terms.
Permits help here. A closed permit, with dated inspection photos, is independent evidence that the roof was installed to code, which is the first thing anyone asks when a warranty claim is made. See roof permits by city.
Put it in the contract
Because the statute's required terms do not include warranties, add these to the written contract yourself:
- Product lineThe exact shingle and accessory names, so the warranty can be identified.
- Manufacturer tierWhich warranty, whether it is registered, and who registers it.
- Workmanship termsYears, scope, interior damage, transfer, and the entity giving it.
- Close-out filePermit number, inspection results, photos and the registration confirmation.
Keep the close-out file with the house records. If you sell, the next owner's inspector will ask for it, and a transferable warranty is only transferable if the paperwork exists.
Comparing warranty offers between quotes
Two quotes for the same roof can carry very different warranties, and the cheaper quote is not always the weaker one. Line them up on the same terms:
| Item | What to write down | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer and product | Brand, line, color | "Comparable shingle" with no name |
| Manufacturer warranty tier | Name of the tier and whether it is registered | A tier that requires certification the roofer cannot show |
| Wind coverage | mph, and the accessories it requires | Accessories missing from the line items |
| Workmanship years | Length and what it covers | Verbal only |
| Who stands behind it | Legal name and city license number | Name differs from the license register |
Then compare price. A quote that is a little higher but names the product, includes the accessories the wind warranty needs, and puts a workmanship term in writing is usually the better roof.
Common questions
Does a roofing warranty cover hail damage in Denver?
Usually not. A manufacturer warranty covers defects in the product, and a workmanship warranty covers installation errors. Hail is weather damage, which is what homeowner's insurance covers. An impact rating such as UL 2218 Class 4 is a test result, not a promise to replace hail-damaged shingles.
What is the difference between a manufacturer and a workmanship warranty?
The manufacturer warrants the materials it made against defects, on its own written terms. The roofing contractor warrants its installation. They are separate documents from separate companies, and if the contractor closes, its workmanship warranty usually goes with it.
Is a "lifetime" shingle warranty really for life?
It is a limited warranty with its own definitions. CertainTeed, for example, pairs a lifetime limited transferable warranty on its Landmark shingle with 10-year SureStart protection for early-life defects. Read how the warranty defines the covered period and what happens to coverage after the early-life window.
Does my contractor have to give me a warranty in Colorado?
C.R.S. 6-22-103 lists what a residential roofing contract must contain, and a workmanship warranty is not on that list. If the roofer offers one, get its length, scope and transfer terms written into the signed contract.
Can a wrong installation void the shingle warranty?
Yes. Manufacturers condition coverage on installation to their instructions, and higher wind ratings can depend on using specified starter and hip-and-ridge products. Thornton's standards also warn that some makers require a paid warranty upgrade to be covered for the stated wind speed.