On this page
What Class 4 means, and what it does not
UL 2218 is a laboratory impact test for prepared roof coverings. Steel balls of four sizes are dropped from set heights onto the same spot twice. The covering passes a class if it shows no crack or split on the top or back. Class 4 is the hardest level.
| Class | Steel ball diameter | Drop height |
|---|---|---|
| Class 1 | 1.25 in | 12 ft |
| Class 2 | 1.5 in | 15 ft |
| Class 3 | 1.75 in | 17 ft |
| Class 4 | 2 in | 20 ft |
Source: GAF, Timberline AS II product page (UL 2218 test summary), read 2026-10-20. This summary comes from a manufacturer, not from UL's own standard text.
Three limits follow from how the test works:
- Steel is not ice. A steel ball is harder and rounder than a hailstone, and lab shingles are new. The rating compares products under one fixed method; it does not predict how a ten-year-old roof behaves in a particular storm.
- "No crack" is the pass mark. A shingle can pass and still show dents, bruises or granule loss. Whether that counts as damage is a policy question, covered below.
- The rating belongs to the product. It says nothing about installation, flashing, vents or skylights, which hail also hits.
The UL 2218 test, drawn to scale
How big Denver-metro hail actually gets
We counted every hail report in NOAA's Storm Events files for the seven metro counties from 2016 to 2025: 869 events on 143 separate hail days. Most stones were under the Class 4 test ball, but not all.
Show the data as a table
| Reported size | Reports |
|---|---|
| Under 1.00 in | 159 reports |
| 1.00–1.74 in | 568 reports |
| 1.75–2.49 in | 114 reports |
| 2.50 in and larger | 28 reports |
Source: NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information, Storm Events Database, details files d2006–d2025 (versions c20260323, c20260519, c20260625, c20260728, c20260819); counted 2026-10-20.
142 reports (16.3%) were 1.75 inches or larger, the size of the Class 3 test ball and above; 28 were 2.5 inches or larger, bigger than the Class 4 ball. The largest single report in the decade was 3.00 inches, in Superior (Boulder County) on 18 June 2018. The full yearly picture is on the Denver metro hail history page.
What the upgrade costs in published Denver prices
Two Denver roofing companies publish per-square prices that separate standard architectural shingles from Class 4. A square is 100 square feet of roof surface. These are the companies' own published figures, not our quotes, and we have not yet collected the 12 dated local quotes our own index needs.
Show the data as a table
| Source and product | Low | High |
|---|---|---|
| Gates: architectural | $450 | $600 |
| Gates: Class 4 | $550 | $750 |
| Core: Duration (arch.) | $650 | $730 |
| Core: Duration Flex IR (C4) | $755 | $825 |
Sources: Gates Roofing (Denver), dated 2026-02-02; Core Roofing Systems (Denver metro), dated 2026; both read 2026-09-23.
On those figures the step from architectural to Class 4 is roughly $100–$150 a square at both companies. On a 30-square roof that is about $3,000–$4,500 before any credit. Core also lists a Class 4 designer shingle (Woodcrest) at $925–$1,150 a square, so "Class 4" covers a wide price band depending on the product line.
Prices its own Denver work by square: Owens Corning Duration architectural $650–$730/sq ($16,000–$23,000 total); Duration Flex IR Class 4 $755–$825/sq ($18,000–$25,000); Woodcrest Class 4 $925–$1,150/sq; stone-coated steel $1,275–$2,300/sq; concrete tile $35,000–$58,000; TPO $13,000–$24,000 and EPDM $14,000–$26,000 on low-slope.
Insurance: credits, deductibles and cosmetic damage
No required credit
"Recoverable depreciation" is the replacement cost minus the actual cash value. A Colorado homeowner has at least 365 days after additional-living-expense coverage ends to replace the property and collect it (36 months for a wildfire total loss). Colorado's homeowner statute contains no roof-specific claim rule and no required credit for impact-resistant roofs. The Division of Insurance's hail advisory instead tells homeowners to ask their insurer about discounts for hail-resistant roofs. In other words, any credit is the insurer's commercial decision.
Sources: C.R.S. 10-4-110.8, Homeowner's insurance; Colorado Division of Insurance, consumer advisory: tips after hailstorms. Read 2026-10-20.
Questions to put to your insurer, in writing
- What premium credit applies for a UL 2218 Class 4 roof, in dollars per year on my policy?
- What proof do you need: product listing, invoice, certificate from the roofer?
- Does my policy exclude or limit cosmetic hail damage, and does that change if I install Class 4?
- Is my wind and hail deductible a percentage of Coverage A, and what is it in dollars?
Divide the upgrade cost by the annual credit to get a payback period in years, then compare it with how long you expect to own the house. If the insurer will not state a credit, the upgrade has to justify itself on fewer claims alone.
Cosmetic damage and matching
No Colorado statute requires an insurer to match undamaged roofing or limits cosmetic-damage exclusions. Matching and cosmetic damage turn on the policy wording and case law (for example Bertisen v. Travelers, D. Colo.). An impact-resistant roof that is dented but still watertight may be exactly the kind of loss a cosmetic exclusion leaves unpaid. That is not an argument against Class 4; it is a reason to read the endorsement before you choose.
Source: Property Insurance Coverage Law blog, summary of Bertisen v. Travelers (D. Colo.) (secondary summary; verify against the policy).
The hail deductible calculator shows what a percentage deductible means in dollars, and the insurance claims guide covers depreciation and the claim timeline.
Strengthen Colorado Homes grants
Senate Bill 26-155, signed 4 June 2026 (effective 12 August 2026), creates the Strengthen Colorado Homes Enterprise inside the Division of Insurance to give retrofit grants such as IBHS FORTIFIED resilient-roof upgrades, funded by a 0.5 percent fee on homeowner premiums from 2027. The law sets no grant amount, rules were not yet adopted when we checked, and grants start in 2027 at the earliest.
Source: Colorado General Assembly, SB26-155, read 2026-10-20. Status checked; grant amounts not set.
Reading a product listing
Impact rating is printed in the manufacturer's specifications, usually as "UL 2218 Class 4" or "FM 4473 / UL 2218 Class 3". The class differs between product lines from the same maker, so check the exact shingle named on your quote.
| Product | Impact rating as listed | Other ratings listed |
|---|---|---|
| IKO Dynasty (laminated asphalt) | FM 4473 / UL 2218 Class 3 | ASTM D3161 Class F, D7158 Class H, ASTM E108/UL 790 Class A fire; 130 mph limited wind warranty |
| IKO Cambridge Cool Colors Plus (laminated asphalt) | FM 4473 Class 3 | D3161 Class F, D7158 Class H, Class A fire; 110 mph wind warranty, 130 mph upgrade |
| DECRA stone-coated steel | UL Class 4 | Class A fire; warranty against penetration by hailstones up to 2.5 in |
Sources: IKO, Dynasty shingle specifications; IKO, Cambridge Cool Colors Plus product page (specifications and standards); DECRA Metal Roofing, home page (stone-coated steel). All read 2026-10-20. We have not tested these products and do not rank them.
Two things to check on the listing besides the class: whether the manufacturer offers any hail warranty at all (most asphalt shingle warranties do not cover hail; DECRA's is an exception for steel), and whether the wind warranty you are quoted requires a specific starter strip or nailing pattern.
Deciding, step by step
- Get the creditAsk your insurer for the Class 4 credit in dollars, in writing.
- Price bothAsk each roofer to quote the same roof in standard and Class 4 shingles.
- Do the paybackUpgrade cost ÷ annual credit = years to break even.
- Check the policyRead the cosmetic-damage and deductible terms before choosing.
If you are replacing the roof after a hail claim, the insurer pays for like kind and quality, so the Class 4 step-up is normally your cost. Make sure the contract lists the exact product, as C.R.S. 6-22-103 already requires the materials to be stated, and keep the wrapper photos for the insurer.
Common questions
What does Class 4 mean on a shingle?
It is the top rating in UL 2218. A 2-inch steel ball is dropped twice on the same spot from 20 feet, and the shingle must not crack or split. It is a lab test with steel, not a promise that hail will never damage the roof.
Do Colorado insurers have to discount a Class 4 roof?
No. Colorado's homeowner-insurance statute contains no required credit for impact-resistant roofs. The Division of Insurance advises asking your own insurer whether a hail-resistant roof earns a discount, so get the amount in writing before you pay for the upgrade.
How much more does a Class 4 shingle roof cost in Denver?
In the published Denver ranges, Gates Roofing prints $550–$750 per square for Class 4 against $450–$600 for architectural, and Core Roofing Systems prints $755–$825 for its Class 4 shingle against $650–$730 for its standard architectural line. Those are contractors' published prices, not ours.
Is a Class 4 roof covered if hail still damages it?
That depends on your policy, not the shingle. Many policies treat dents or granule loss that do not let water in as cosmetic, and some exclude cosmetic damage. Ask for the exact wording before and after the upgrade.
Can I get a state grant for an impact-resistant roof?
Not yet. Senate Bill 26-155 created the Strengthen Colorado Homes Enterprise in 2026 to fund retrofit grants such as IBHS FORTIFIED roofs, but grants start in 2027 at the earliest and no amount is set in law.